Twitter Facebook LinkedIn GooglePlus

Cheapest Car Insurance Rates In Pennsylvania (2018)

In a perfect world, finding cheap car insurance in Pennsylvania would be an easy endeavor. Unfortunately, there are dozens of variables that affect your insurance premiums, and there’s no shortage of insurance providers vying for your business.

To make things easier, our team crunched the numbers and compared premiums from nine leading insurance providers to find low cost auto insurance in PA for:

No Recent AccidentsTeen Drivers
Drivers With A DUISenior Drivers

Best Rates For Drivers With No Recent Accidents

$155/month estimate

$/month estimate

Is your driving record clean? Or do you have an accident history? It should come as no surprise that your traffic record has a major impact on your auto insurance premiums.

As a safe driver, you shouldn’t have to pay out the nose for coverage, and even if your current rates are relatively low, you may still be able to save by switching to Progressive or Allstate—the two companies that triumphed in our quote comparison for accident-free drivers in Pennsylvania.

Best Rates For Teen Drivers

$104/month estimate

$199/month estimate

Young drivers are statistically more likely to cause a crash, which is why teenagers tend to pay higher premiums than their adult counterparts. Finding cheap car insurance rates for teenagers in Pennsylvania is no easy task, but our research indicates that State Farm is your best bet if you’re looking for Pennsylvania’s minimum required coverage.

Best Rates For Drivers With A DUI

$155/month estimate

$/month estimate

Any traffic infraction can influence your insurance premiums, but a DUI conviction is typically followed by a particularly significant hike in monthly rates. Allstate was identified by our research to provide the cheapest auto insurance rates for drivers with a DWI or DUI conviction in Pennsylvania.

Best Rates For Senior Drivers

$137/month estimate

$/month estimate

Allstate was found by our study to offer the best car insurance premiums for motorists in this category. Senior drivers usually travel less annual mileage than other motorists, which often translates into lower monthly premiums. Our study focused on a 65 year old who commuted 4,000 miles per year.


A 29-year-old driver with no recent accidents or traffic citations was used as the default policyholder in our study. The annual mileage was 12,000, and the vehicle being insured was a 2014 Toyota Corolla. To estimate the monthly premiums, we looked at average insurance rates for females and males from five PA zip codes. Liability coverage limits of 50/100/25 and uninsured motorist coverage limits of 50/100/25 were used for all driver types except teenagers.

What Is The Minimum Auto Insurance Coverage Required By Law In Pennsylvania?

In Pennsylvania, all drivers are required to carry car insurance that meets the following minimum limits:

  • $15,000 To Cover Bodily Injuries To One Person
  • $30,000 To Cover Bodily Injuries Per Accident
  • $5,000 To Cover Property Damage
  • $5,000 In Medical Benefits Per Collision

Penalties For Driving Without Car Insurance In Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania law requires every driver to carry insurance, and even first-time offenders face harsh punishment. If you cannot produce proof of the state-required minimum insurance upon the request of a law enforcement officer, your vehicle registration will be immediately suspended for three months.

During this time, your plates, card, sticker and driver’s license must be handed over to the Pennsylvania Department of Transport. Neither you nor anyone else may drive your vehicle until your driving privileges and registration have been reinstated through paying a hefty fee and providing the Department with verifiable proof that your vehicle is insured.

You will also be fined $300 for driving without insurance.

What Is The Civil Penalty Option?

State law enables you to pay a $500 civil penalty upfront to cut down the three-month suspension of your vehicle’s registration. While it’s costly, this will enable family or friends to use the vehicle until your driving privileges are later restored upon paying the reinstatement fee and providing the Department with proof that your vehicle is adequately insured.

However, if you are caught driving without insurance within a year of a previous offense, you will not be able to make use of this option.

How To File A Insurance Claim In Pennsylvania

1. Dial 911

A prompt and detailed police report is the backbone of any rock-solid claim. Plus, in most states, it is mandatory to report serious road accidents to the municipal traffic department.

Police not only will secure the scene, ensuring that you, any passengers and other motorists are safe, but will also collect statements from the parties involved and anyone who may have witnessed the crash. Officers may also secure evidence from the crash site.

2. Gather Info

You should take down the names, phone numbers, plate numbers, insurance information, and addresses of all motorists involved in the accident. Pro tip: Be sure to collect the personal details of any eyewitnesses, too.

3. Snap Pictures

Using your phone, document any damage and/or injuries caused by the accident. Our Geeks suggest snapping a few extra shots of weather conditions, road markings and anything else that might help provide context.

4. Visit The Doctor

You might not have any surface injuries, but even a small crash can cause untold pain in the near future. This is because impact forces put immense strain on the most vulnerable parts of your body – such as your neck and spine – and can lead to slipped discs, fractures and sprains.

Your doctor will be able to assess your condition and conclude whether you require further medical treatment. This not only is important to your own well-being but also will ensure that you include all the relevant medical expenses as part of your eventual claim.

5. Start Your Claim

Contact your insurer to figure out what you need to start filing your claim and to report the accident. Be sure to include additional evidence such as photographs from the scene, the personal details of any witnesses, a doctor’s diagnosis of your injuries and information you think might aid the insurance company and strengthen your claim.

Can I File A Claim If I Was Partially At Fault For The Accident?

Remember this: Pennsylvania is one of very few “no-fault” states. This system means that drivers can rely on the personal injury protection component of their own auto insurance policy to cover a portion of their medical bills resulting from a crash, whether they are to blame or not.

However, you can opt for what is known as a “limited tort” option when buying insurance in Pennsylvania, which will help lower your premiums but, in most cases, does not cover injuries caused by a crash.

Our Geeks recommend buying “no-fault” insurance as the higher premium will give you peace of mind that a crash won’t come at the cost of your next family vacation.

How To Prepare For Any Accident

Next time you are about hit the road, make sure you’re ready for the worst. Pack this:

  • An emergency kit including thick bandages; and
  • A document folder containing everything from your insurance information and healthcare coverage details.



cheapest car insurance in pennsylvania

Browse through our blog to find helpful FAQs about car insurance.


If you have a question or comment to share, please post it to our Facebook and/or Twitter page.

Find Cheap Insurance By State
Find Cheap Insurance By Driver Type
Car Insurance FAQs
How Can I Get My Car Insurance Premiums Reduced? Should I Buy Uninsured Motorist Coverage? What Factors Affect My Auto Insurance Rates? When Can My Car Insurance Company Increase My Premiums? What Are Common Reasons Why Car Insurance Claims Are Denied?